Rassie Erasmus: How South Africa’s maverick coach divides rugby
But there is no doubt, by the letter of the law, that Erasmus is wrong – certainly in terms of the platform and terms he chose for his complaints. In July World Rugby introduced new rules...
But there is no doubt, by the letter of the law, that Erasmus is wrong – certainly in terms of the platform and terms he chose for his complaints.
In July World Rugby introduced new rules around criticism of officials. It specifically targeted “comments which, viewed objectively, a reasonable person would conclude were an attack on the credibility or competence of the match officials”.
Mentioning “match-fixing” undermines the officials in exactly that way.
Considering Erasmus’ previous, including an hour-long monologue bemoaning officiating of a first-Test defeat by the Lions in 2021 and a series of tweets after a loss to France a year later, he may be fortunate to only be banned for six matches.
World Rugby, perhaps pre-empting the reaction in South Africa, was clear that it was not punishing Erasmus for asking questions.
“Robust, respectful debate is natural, but teams have access to well-established and supported channels and protocols for raising officiating matters before and after matches,” it said in its judgement.
“Challenging a decision is not the same as questioning an official’s integrity or making comments that expose them to personal abuse.”
For many South Africans, though, Erasmus is still an outlaw hero.
World Rugby, based in Dublin, is seen by them as tilted towards the north.
Australian Brett Robinson, the current chairman, is the first figure from outside the Six Nations countries to hold the organisation’s top job since it became an elected position.
The World Cup has been lifted by South Africa on four occasions, but held there only once.
Japan coach Eddie Jones, Erasmus’ fellow maverick, recently suggested Ireland’s political clout, external was behind his team’s home game being staged in Australia rather than Tokyo.
South Africa were a powerful voice against the possible moves to “depower” the scrum – a key part of the Springbok game – at a February conference to discuss future law tweaks.
Erasmus’ public pronouncements have fuelled conspiracy theories weaved from those threads. They have also made an all-time great team harder for outsiders to love.
Whether it is a deliberate ploy is hard to tell.
Certainly Erasmus is a repeat offender, but his offences have also come in his second language. He is an Afrikaans speaker.
Some also see instinctive honesty rather than premeditated ploy in his public speaking.
“He also has almost no filters, so he will speak his mind without fully appreciating the consequences of what he has done,” his biographer David O’Sullivan told BBC Sport in 2023.
Whatever the motivation, the consequences keep coming – for Erasmus, but also the rest of world rugby.
Referees Nic Berry and Wayne Barnes, previous targets of Erasmus’ criticism, have detailed the effects it had on them.
Berry described “a character assassination” that caused “immeasurable damage”. He has not refereed a South Africa game in the five years since.
Barnes’ wife and children were threatened over social media.
South Africa’s latest appeal to their supporters not to abuse officials, external may be too late for referee Andrea Piardi and his television match official Matteo Liperini, who oversaw France’s win on Friday.
There is a wider question too.
For a complex sport, the image of a world champion coach publicly criticising officials does not little to dispel a wavering viewer’s assumption that it is too intricate and confusing to justify their attention.
South Africa will always line up alongside their rebel chief.
But the patience of the rest of the rugby world with Erasmus’ antics is wearing ever thinner.



No Comment! Be the first one.